Comment

Comment by chromakode

While I agree with this premise, taking an extreme view, practically all software which users routinely update are vulnerable to the first party / author being compelled to ship a harmful release.

The lack of a distribution trust model for the web has long bummed me out, but even snake oil E2EE is a good thing because it makes an active (and potentially detectable) intervention necessary to exploit a client.

Supply chain attacks remain a huge mess. Unless you can validate the worthiness and authenticity of an update, or sandbox it sufficiently, most software can become a threat.

A more manual, opt-in update process for web apps (via service workers) would be a nice innovation, but I doubt it would provide much more safety to non technical end users, since the harder question is whether a particular update is harmful. Solving that verification problem is the crux of the issue regardless of how rapidly software updates.

parent chromakode 3 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton