Comment

Comment by tredre3

Whatsapp succeeded with XMPP because they defined a superset and their only client implements 100% of it. This isn't applicable to XMPP at large at all.

I tried getting E2EE working. There are 3 standards. Some clients implement one or two of them. Some clients none. It's a nightmare to get them to talk together.

Then you have all the other 400 XEPs that may or may not be implemented by clients. Things like file transfer, typing indicator, video chat, avatars, group chats.

The only way XMPP becomes relevant again is if they choose a subset of REQUIRED features and clients must implement them all to be considered XMPP2-compatible.

parent tredre3 3 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton