Comment

Comment by xg15

Not a friend of nuclear, but I think OP's first point (duck curve) and second point (no place for baseload) contradict each other somewhat.

Or more specifically, why couldn't you convert any baseload plant into a "flexible supply" plant by adding storage?

You can interpret the post in two ways: Either, solar capacity will grow to such an extent that eventually it will be enough to cover all demand: Meaning, during summer days, there will be enough supply to cover the immediate demand and fill up storage enough to cover all evenings, nights and winter days. If that were the case then there wouldn't be the need for any power sources except solar and storage and we'd have basically solved energy. Hooray!

However, that seems pretty unrealistic. The second interpretation of the article is that solar will grow (and will be able to contribute to storage to some extent) but will not be able to fully cover the dark hours - hence the duck curve. For those times, other energy sources are still needed.

However, if there is still a need for other energy sources, then why couldn't baseload plants cover that need? Yes, it's only for a few hours per day (in summer), but then the baseload plant is needed the rest of the time to fill up storage - as solar, by initial assumption, would not be sufficient to do that.

parent xg15 3 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton