Comment

Comment by adsfgiodsnrio

You are badly misrepresenting the content of your sources.

[1] says:

>The owls are endangered from many sides. One of the biggest threats uses the Shoreline golf course. A bleak Mountain View report three months ago noted there have been deaths “due to direct contact between golf balls and burrowing owls.”

They do not blame only cats. They discuss cats in particular but do mention there are other threats. I will grant that this one confusingly-worded paragraph is not enough background.

They also do not call for the killing of all cats. The article mostly criticizes the practice of feeding cats, not TNR or adoption.

[2] says:

>Feral cats are supreme predators and actively prey upon burrowing owls. One study in Florida found owl mortality by cats accounted for 30 percent of deaths (Millsap and Bear, 1988). Cats also impact burrowing owls indirectly by decimating small bird and rodent populations, reducing the available food supply for burrowing owls.

One suggested solution is to:

>Proactively discourage all feeding of cats in Shoreline

It is exactly the same message as the NYT article.

[3] calls out the threat of cats first and foremost.

>There are many factors that could explain the low numbers. The owls are ground-nesting, living in holes hollowed out by squirrels. That can leave them vulnerable to a long list of predators, including foxes, skunks and raccoons. Feral cats are considered the worst of the lot, preying on owls as well as the small birds and rodents that make up the owls' main food supply. In fact, a released cat last year ended up mauling one prolific male owl, Kleinhaus said.

>In the aftermath of the shutdown, the local feral cat population predictably exploded[8], and the burrowing owl population at Shoreline Park went down to zero[9].

You seem to acknowledge that the large cat population was in fact a threat to owls, but still object to the NYT story.

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton