Comment

Comment by ninkendo

Nope, you're in an inertial reference frame when in free-fall. Ignoring air resistance, if you were to take an apple out of your pocket and place it next to you in mid-air, it would be motionless relative to yourself. Put a box around you with no windows and you'll have no idea whether you're floating through space in the absence of gravity, or if you're free-falling inside a gravity well.

This is the main difference between general relativity and the newtonian notion of gravity: GR says gravity is just spacetime curvature, and by following an inertial (geodesic) path through spacetime, it appears to be acceleration to certain observers, but is in fact inertial. Newtonian mechanics says instead that gravity is a force and you're indeed accelerating, but it's a view that breaks down at high mass/speed, and GR makes correct predictions where Newtonian mechanics does not, so we generally prefer the GR interpretation.

parent ninkendo 3 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton