Comment by kuhzaam

What are the "all things equal" here, though? I would tend to disagree that someone who can complete the coding challenge faster is the objectively better candidate. Especially if we are talking about leet coding, where there are people who study their asses off and memorize the common leet code problems. Or maybe the coding challenge isn't leet code, but just so happens to be something that the candidate has done before, or has done recently. Just because one candidate lucked out and has done this very specific thing, doesn't mean they are better than a candidate who could figure it out in half a day, if given a little more time to do so.