Comment

Comment by waqf

You're imagining the tax rates as being much higher than they would actually have to be (and I think you also missed that the taxes you pay always end up being a tax-rate proportion applied to the amount you earned that year). Assume for simplicity that people typically have a 40-year working life.

Then when you earn your first $500k in five years, that will be taxed at a rate appropriate to someone who earns $500k over their working life (that is, $12.5k/year). What's the U.S. tax rate at that level, currently? 15%?

So I envision your annual taxes, in your example, as looking something like:

  Year  1     Earn $100k   Rate 10%   Tax  $10k
  Year  2     Earn $100k   Rate 10%   Tax  $10k
  Year  3     Earn $100k   Rate 10%   Tax  $10k
  Year  4     Earn $100k   Rate 15%   Tax  $15k
  Year  5     Earn $100k   Rate 15%   Tax  $15k
  Year  6     Earn  $10k   Rate 15%   Tax $1.5k
  Year  7     Earn  $10k   Rate 15%   Tax $1.5k
  Year  8     Earn  $10k   Rate 15%   Tax $1.5k
  Year  9     Earn  $10k   Rate 15%   Tax $1.5k
  Year 10     Earn  $10k   Rate 15%   Tax $1.5k
You won't move into the 25% band until you've earned something like $1.3m over your life.
parent waqf 14 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton