Comment

Comment by seanhunter

I hear this a lot and it's in a lot of "explainer" videos on youtube and so on. The idea that banks have a special state-sponsored privilege to create credit is completely and very obviously untrue.

Try this thought experiment. You and I are in a bar. We order drinks but oh no the bar's card machine is down and you don't have cash. No problem I'll lend you a tenner.

1) Am I a bank?

2) Did I first contact the state to check it was ok to create money in the form of a loan to you?

I go back to the bar on another day on my own. Oh no! Their card machine is down again! This time I don't have cash on me. No problem the barman sees me all the time I can have the drink this time and pay up when I next get there and either have cash or their card machine is working.

3) Are they a bank?

4) Did they first contact the state to check it was ok to create money in the form of a loan to me?

The answer to all these questions is obviously no. Credit is created throughout the economy at all levels and it is not a special function perculiar to banks.

parent seanhunter 3 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton