Comment

Comment by mlloydw

Quantum and Newtonian physics are both just conceptual models to help ourselves understand and predict the things around us. They're useful for describing reality but neither of them are accurate representations of the real deal. All models break down at some limits.

To imagine one model "being merely a superstructure" on another implies that the limit doesn't exist and the two models are, in fact, the same thing. If you expand that idea to all other models, they would all eventually merge into one grand unified theory that accurately explains every single occurrencence in the universe. A nice idea conceptually, but we're at best no where near that and at worst have brains that will find the nuance of the universe impossible to comprehend in totality.

Any model that is useful for understanding and predicting the universe is worth sticking with, as long as you understand the limits where it applies. If path integrals happen to unlock some new insight that seems evidentially correct, it doesn't really matter if it ties into other theories.

parent mlloydw 3 years ago

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton