Comment

Comment by knaik94

I do. I equally scold anyone that says MDMA or LSD is the cure all of depression.

It's not an analogy. There is no mechanical difference between someone using Amphetamines to treat their ADHD and someone using insulin to treat their diabetes. There are just as many external as internal factors that go into how someone can get diabetes and what dosage of insulin they need at a specific moment in time. Science has advanced to a point where diabetes specifically can be monitored easily by a patient. The same is true of hypertension.

The difference for mental health issues is that there is no easy quantifiable way to diagnose someone.

Every organ is the most complicated organ in the human body, at a certain level every organ has a mechanism science doesn't understand yet. That's not a valid argument.

The same is true for pain management. And Multiple Sclerosis.

I would suggest you look into the modern state of neurophysiology and neuropsychopharmacology. The "we don't understand" is not true anymore. The reality is that there are so many factors affecting a certain visible outcome that it's hard to specify a root cause.

I am not a medical professional, I have only taken some 300 and 400/grad level courses in psychology.

parent knaik94 4 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton