Comment

Comment by captainmuon

Having worked with devicetrees and hated it, I don't like this idea. I don't like the modern world of ARM and embedded where you have hardcoded firmware images for every single device. I like the x86 model, where you have a one size fits all boot disk which just loads different drivers. You don't port your OS to a new computer, you just write drivers for the new hardware parts. And your hardware describes itself to the OS.

Granted, UEFI is grotesquely complicated. Probably you could replace most of it with a EEPROM that has a mapping of device ID to memory address, and some instructions how to speak to the embedded controller (basically, ACPI).

Unfortunately, UEFI/ACPI or simliar seems to be going nowhere in the ARM world, so it doesn't seem installing Windows/Linux is going to be as easy on ARM as on x86 anytime soon.

parent captainmuon 4 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton