Comment

Comment by lelanthran

> Simply, that you can’t compare laptops solely on a cost basis easily.

But they aren't doing that!*

They're specifically comparing performance between two similarly-priced laptops[1]. That's what "benchmark" means.

If this was a review between the two laptops I'd agree with you, but it isn't a review, it's a benchmark suite.

> Does the Ryzen system come with a full aluminum enclosure?

> Does it come with a screen with P3 color, 400 nits peak brightness, and HDR support?

> What is the battery size on both machines, and how long do each last?

> How thin is it? How light it it? How fast does it charge? How much does this affect you daily?

All of these are valid questions, just not for a benchmark. The benchmark is one set of inputs a potential purchaser would take into account, with the other inputs being all those things you mentioned.

[1] I assume that they're similarly priced - I skipped the introduction and went straight to the benchmarks.

parent lelanthran 4 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton