Comment

Comment by dcolkitt

One thing to note is that while Celsius, a centralized and opaque yield platform, collapsed, not a single major DeFi protocol failed during a period of enormous stress. MakerDAO, Aave, Uniswap, Curve, Lido and Compound all had perfect 24/7 uptime with zero losses due to unrecoverable debt.

This pretty clearly strengthens the case for pure and transparent DeFi, where anybody can inspect the health of the protocol or the rules of the immutable code. In contrast Celsius failed because it was an opaque black box that primarily lent to other opaque black boxes like Three Arrows Capital.

For a long-time a lot of people just getting into crypto felt like the CeDeFi platforms like Celsius or BlockFi were "safer" than the pure on-chain protocols like Aave or Curve because they didn't have to worry about managing their own keys, there were humans in charge, and a nice corporate entity standing behind it their deposits. As it turns out, decentralized autonomous protocols were substantially safer.

parent dcolkitt 4 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton