Boy. This is the best explanation of this belief I've come across yet. It's coherent and reasonable, even if I disagree.
My highest scoring StackOverflow answer [1] (and my most controversial) is on exactly this topic and _no one_ in any competing answer have given _any_ sensible explanation of their reasoning. I've genuinely never understood their thought process, despite trying really, *really* hard. This explains it a bit, even though I totally disagree.
There are other tools for helping differentiate different varieties of 404 or 401. There are status codes, there's _nothing_ preventing you from returning a payload with explanation or overriding the Reason Phrase. If your HTTP client is too fragile to handle a very common usage pattern for HTTP status codes then pick a different one.
My highest scoring StackOverflow answer [1] (and my most controversial) is on exactly this topic and _no one_ in any competing answer have given _any_ sensible explanation of their reasoning. I've genuinely never understood their thought process, despite trying really, *really* hard. This explains it a bit, even though I totally disagree.
There are other tools for helping differentiate different varieties of 404 or 401. There are status codes, there's _nothing_ preventing you from returning a payload with explanation or overriding the Reason Phrase. If your HTTP client is too fragile to handle a very common usage pattern for HTTP status codes then pick a different one.
---
[1] - https://stackoverflow.com/questions/11746894/what-is-the-pro...