> For what it's worth, every GitHub project has a mechanism for submitting issues. It's better Open Source spirit to utilize these tools as intended.
Are project issues the right place for reviews of claims? Negative point sure would be nice to have as github issues (and checking for some easily searchables: they seem to exist [1,2]) but many of the points in the review don't suite issues well. I don't think "you can open tickets" would be a useful response to "wat" [3] either.
Alternatively your suggestion was for me to wade through the issues to figure out if the critizism holds, which I find is not a helpful suggestion either, as many of them are not particularly well searchable. Also, I assumed, as the review got a bit of attention and the creator was in the thread, it would lead to an interesting response a-la "we are aware, fixing it, many fixed already, here is our roadmap" with possible discussion. I am a bit saddened that it turned out to be much more hostile and negative.
[1] https://github.com/vlang/v/issues/11059 (won't fix undefined behavior in generated code)
[2] https://github.com/vlang/v/issues/7519 (fixed missing openssl header)
[3] https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/wat
Are project issues the right place for reviews of claims? Negative point sure would be nice to have as github issues (and checking for some easily searchables: they seem to exist [1,2]) but many of the points in the review don't suite issues well. I don't think "you can open tickets" would be a useful response to "wat" [3] either.
Alternatively your suggestion was for me to wade through the issues to figure out if the critizism holds, which I find is not a helpful suggestion either, as many of them are not particularly well searchable. Also, I assumed, as the review got a bit of attention and the creator was in the thread, it would lead to an interesting response a-la "we are aware, fixing it, many fixed already, here is our roadmap" with possible discussion. I am a bit saddened that it turned out to be much more hostile and negative.
[1] https://github.com/vlang/v/issues/11059 (won't fix undefined behavior in generated code)
[2] https://github.com/vlang/v/issues/7519 (fixed missing openssl header)
[3] https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/wat