But that’s exactly what the Roe v Wade decision was - decide what policy you want, then have the court come up with an argument as to why that right exists.
It’s not supposed to work that way. The legislature makes laws, the court interprets under the framework of the Constitution.
Precedent is important, but it’s not supposed to create law out of thin air. It’s supposed to be based on a firm set of decisions that flow from the Constitution and law.
It’s not supposed to work that way. The legislature makes laws, the court interprets under the framework of the Constitution.
Precedent is important, but it’s not supposed to create law out of thin air. It’s supposed to be based on a firm set of decisions that flow from the Constitution and law.