Comment

Comment by mjburgess

Reposting my comment (which is leaf'd off a dead one):

Crypto is "cult by design" in much the way all greater-fool scams are. Namely, since coins are incredibly deflationary, wealth accumulates to a small number of early-stakers whilst the long-tail people buying-in provide their liquidity (/cash) so they can exit at an extreme multiple of buy-in. Everyone is relying on "more fools" to create a longer-tail from their stating position so they can exit higher. Meaning, whatever position you enter at, you have to evangelise like crazy.

I dont think anyone has ever yet explained how this is meant to function as a currency. Indeed, crypto people are dead-set on explaining everything except how this works as a currency. Long-and-short of it: extremely deflationary assets are terrible currencies.

One reason they're terrible is they transfer power over the economic system to early-stakers, as they have all the wealth. This is just feudalism where land=coin. So crypto people, sitting on a lot of coins, who urge adoption arent trying to "free" the economy, they're trying to own it.

It is just a bigger-fool scam, so it wont work -- at some point the tail won't be long enough, and it'll collapse (but this could take decades, as some scams do keep finding enough people to sustain them). So I dont think there's much danger in it -- but, lets be clear: any corporation which accepts bitcoins is thereby recognising an essentially feudal type of economic power.

Most holders of coin-wealth didn't earn it, they are taking it from the fools currently buying-in. Accepting crypto as currency, means giving early-stakes a way of exiting the scam at incredible multiples.

parent mjburgess 4 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton