Comment

Comment by dogma1138

Not a MOND proponent but why does it exactly contradict it?

It’s a UDG with very little to no star forming gas and very low overall mass and density, looking up the galaxy it’s about the same size Milky Way but has less than 0.5% of its stars and much less than that when it comes to overall mass.

It seems that there are some papers that attempt to reconcile the observations with MOND and on the face of it the velocities expected if MOND holds true and are not far off from the current observations.

https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.04167

Considering the distance of the galaxy (72m light years) and the difficulty of establishing the actual mass of UDGs and even globular clusters at that distance it doesn’t look like a MOND killer not nearly as much as gravitational waves and the overall challenges to generalize MOND and make it relativistic.

parent dogma1138 4 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton