Comment

Comment by ptsneves

I come from Linux land so some of the details flew over my head. With that said, is there not a valgrind equivalent for Windows? The sentinel thing seems to a default functionality to the valgrind virtual machine. I would expect that the initial part of the investigation would be automatically done by valgrind. Of course reading the whole post it looks like it would not get very far.

The other thing is, how can a system call block a thread but somehow that same thread runs other stuff in between that blocking call? Even if that is possible that sounds like a dangerous game to play, and this class of bugs seems natural.

I can imagine the scenario where a thread is cancelled mid system call, but it will be the kernel that will cancel the thread and responsible to know that half way syscalls need to be cleaned up. This way the application does not get system call call leaks? Also if i remember one debugging session correctly, when you have a blocking syscall interrupted you will get a sigabort on linux.

parent ptsneves 5 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton