The question should be "does my standup provide enough value to the participants to be worth the time? Why or why not? Are there other ways in which we can provide this value?". There is no 1 size fits all solution. Some teams may not find any value in standups, so they should be removed. Some teams find it a valuable time to sync up as a team so they should be kept. Some teams adapt standups to add value in ways that were not originally intended.
All I see here are arguments around a one size fits all solutions. Be fluid. Observe, listen to your team, and adapt.
All I see here are arguments around a one size fits all solutions. Be fluid. Observe, listen to your team, and adapt.