Comment by drnonsense42

I disagree strongly with this sentiment. Clearly Zillow is not going to buy all the houses in America and turn us into serfs overnight - that is an absurd strawman. What? Zillow is far from the only actor here trying to enter this space. It's quite ridiculous to claim, as you are, that industrial-scale home speculation is doomed to fail since there are boom and bust cycles and therefore we don't need to worry. That's ridiculous. We really don't have any direct, past precedent for this type of situation. It is rational to be concerned here. The fact that Zillow failed on their initial attempt does not imply that this can't work - it just means they're one of the first making a serious attempt and, unsurprisingly, they got overzealous and it didn't work on the first try! Quant firms for the stock market in the early 90s did not work overnight even though the market was much more inefficient than it is now. It takes time for groups of highly qualified and very smart people to figure this stuff out - but, they will.