Comment

Comment by SequoiaHope

I have a theory that we can eliminate 90% of the required labor in our economy with the following strategy:

End “consumerism” behavior where every problem is perceived to have a solution in the form of a quick product you can buy - much of that is a psychological trick played by marketers and rarely solves the real problem.

Take note of the goods and services we really need. Things like food, shelter, shoes, etc.

Design machines which can produce those vital things in a fully automated or highly automated way. The point of this part is to reduce the marginal cost of one more item as close to zero as possible. This makes sharing easier as it becomes cheaper to share with one more person.

Make those machines completely open source, designed for repair and long life.

Create a system where people can acquire equal ownership shares in the machines they rely on. For any given machine those users work together to keep the machine operational and producing.

Land must be held in common (the legal device used today would be a public land trust) and housing, farmland, and manufacturing space is allotted to people based on need. (Look at the public housing system in Vienna Austria as an example.)

Develop a culture where getting rich is not the goal but making sure everyone has what they need is. This has worked in other human societies before so this should be possible.

Then everyone shares the output of their machines with their other shareholders. Each person owns shares in many machines.

Under this system, there is no ownership class which can suck up all the surplus value. Instead, every person receives the benefit of automation.

In such a world I believe the average persons necessary working hours would be maybe 5 hours a week. We could spend our lives with friends and family, or reading and writing, painting or programming. Most of the necessary work would be done by volunteers who enjoy what they are doing. Work that people do not enjoy could be shared in rotation.

It’s all a voluntary and market based system but captures the main thrust of Marx’s critique of capitalism - the problem with an ownership class sucking up all the surplus value in society.

We could do this. End consumerism, make everything open source, share land, know when you have enough and work to serve others in your community.

Anyway that’s my theory.

parent SequoiaHope 5 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton