Comment

Comment by dvt

Apologies for the hot take, but imo GitHub has been really knocking it out of the park with terrible ideas lately (remember how everyone fell all over themselves during the Copilot release?). This is an absolutely worthless visualization that only impresses those that haven't heavily worked with visualizations. A few points right off the bat:

    - Labels are way too small, so you'll need to zoom in..
    - ...but if you zoom in, you'll need to pan...
    - ...and if you need to pan, you lose context
    - Hovering over "connected files" is just a jumbled mess
Case in point: look at the `paperjs/paper.js` example they themselves provide. There's a big circle called "packages" and inside that circle, two smaller circles that all contain the exact same files: "package.json," "index.js," and "README.md" -- how is this insightful in any way? I need to go to the repo to actually see that one of the folders is called "paper-jsdom" and the other one "paper-jsdom-canvas." The visualization literally confuses me more than just looking at the repo.

I don't mean to be overly negative, but it's just not a good visualization and no one will ever seriously use this.

parent dvt 5 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton