Comment

Comment by TeMPOraL

GP is asking for the opposite. They're asking for code unfolding.

That is, given a "clean code like":

  auto DoTheThing(Stuff stuff) -> Result {
    const auto foo = ProcessSth(stuff);
    const auto bar = ValidateSthElse(stuff);

    return DoSth(foo, bar);
  }
The tool would inline all the function calls. That is, for each of ProcessSth(), ValidateSthElse() and DoSth(), it would automatically perform the task of "copy the function body, paste it at the call site, and massage the caller to make it work". It's sometimes called the "inline function" refactoring - the inverse of "extract function"/"extract method" refactoring.

I'd really, really want such a tool. Particularly one where the changes were transient - not modifying the source code, just overlaying it with a read-only replacement. Also interactive. My example session is:

- Take the "clean code" function that just calls a bunch of other functions. With one key combination, inline all these functions.

- In the read-only inlined overlay, mark some other function calls and inline them too.

- Rinse, repeat, until I can read the overlay top-to-bottom and understand what the code is actually doing.

parent TeMPOraL 5 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton