Comment

Comment by hardwaregeek

Some of these recipes seem decent if you're already somewhat experienced and have developed cook's intuition. Otherwise they're way too vague. For instance, the chicken parm recipe:

- There should be a photo of how to slice the chicken breast. Saying "through their width" isn't good enough. I had to explain what "lengthwise" was once because my friend cut all the vegetables the exact opposite of it.

- Pound with what? A lot of people will come up with very bad answers to this question.

- How much flour? How much egg? I'll bet that plenty of beginners will use a tablespoon of flour or a singular egg

- Ditto with oil. Beginners do not know how much oil is necessary to fry stuff

- How high heat? You probably want to turn down the heat after the oil starts smoking.

- Is there a single mention of adding salt? Sounds like a pretty bland recipe

I don't mean to be too harsh but recipes are hard. There's a reason why professional recipe developers have developed certain standards like measurements, terms (folding batter, shimmering oil, etc.), and development procedures (cross testing).

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton