Comment

Comment by vbtemp

I enthusiastically believed this in the past, but then I started observing the reverse: Code reviews became gatekeeping for junior developers... In other words, junior developers were using it as opportunities to assert power (via obstruction). Of course this was idiosyncratic to the company and team.

I've become less positive toward code reviews over the years as well - the low-hanging fruit of style checking, linting, and related stuff has been automated away. Moreover, people are busy and when they do code reviews, they are mostly looking for easy stuff to pick at. What ends up getting avoided is the far more important algorithm, design and architecture reviews that really require a much bigger cognitive load.

parent vbtemp 5 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton