Turns out I also hang out here sometimes ;-)
I was about to reply point by point with arguments, but I changed my mind:
I don't think I'd be interested in that conversation, the comment above is worse than a public display of a very poor understanding of Git and Pijul: it also shows a complete ignorance of other actors in the market. It turns out the market leader for big repositories, Perforce, is itself based on RCS, possibly (but I don't know for sure, since Perforce is proprietary) because RCS scales much better to large binary assets than other solutions (I'd argue Pijul solves that, but that's beside my point).
I am a big fan of Git, Mercurial and Darcs myself, my co-author on Pijul was actually a maintainer of Darcs for many years, and I'm actively collaborating with the maintainers of Mercurial at the moment. And even though Perforce and Plastic are closed-source, they do solve one problem (scalability) which distributed systems are only beginning to understand (if there's one thing I think we've achieved with Pijul, it is about getting beyond the "distributed vs. scalable" trade-off).
Here's my take on the comment above: I don't think you can build good systems without understanding how others are made. There are no free lunches, no silver bullets, no geniuses. Only good ideas, bibliography, and hard work.
I was about to reply point by point with arguments, but I changed my mind:
I don't think I'd be interested in that conversation, the comment above is worse than a public display of a very poor understanding of Git and Pijul: it also shows a complete ignorance of other actors in the market. It turns out the market leader for big repositories, Perforce, is itself based on RCS, possibly (but I don't know for sure, since Perforce is proprietary) because RCS scales much better to large binary assets than other solutions (I'd argue Pijul solves that, but that's beside my point).
I am a big fan of Git, Mercurial and Darcs myself, my co-author on Pijul was actually a maintainer of Darcs for many years, and I'm actively collaborating with the maintainers of Mercurial at the moment. And even though Perforce and Plastic are closed-source, they do solve one problem (scalability) which distributed systems are only beginning to understand (if there's one thing I think we've achieved with Pijul, it is about getting beyond the "distributed vs. scalable" trade-off).
Here's my take on the comment above: I don't think you can build good systems without understanding how others are made. There are no free lunches, no silver bullets, no geniuses. Only good ideas, bibliography, and hard work.