Comment

Comment by nerdjon

Reading the article I am still struggling to understand why exactly you would transition away from something that has a ton of community support and a lot of people use (you are more likely to find a developer with Docker experience than Buildpack).

This just seems like a more opinionated DockerFile that doesn't give you the power to change things that you may need. You will end up being stuck somewhere down the road and being forced to rewrite it as a DockerFile anyways.

If you really want to make it easier for your engineers, stick with a DockerFile and have a couple common internal images that they pull from instead and just put their code in. If they need more flexibility they can switch to pulling a standard image (or you have the control to improve your base image) but you are sticking with Docker Syntax.

Is there something I am missing here?

parent nerdjon 5 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton