This is a refreshing read, every time I ask someone what they like about GraphQL or read an article about the benefits of GraphQL I get the same boilerplate, non-answers that made me avoid GraphQL on my latest app after working with it on 2 freelance projects over the last couple years.
The tooling around Apollo is pretty good, and that’s great but so many of the “why GraphQL” arguments are either short sided, assume you are doing REST badly, or imply you are an organization that is much bigger and has scaling problems most of the projects I’ve worked on do not have. So far I am very happy I went back to a REST API.
Oh and here’s another REST benefit: when working on my REST API I spend most of my time thinking about good API design and testing practices. When working with GraphQL I spent most of my time figuring out how GraphQL ecosystem libraries worked. I would much rather spend my time thinking about how to do the job well than how to glue together an ecosystem of tools that someone else designed. Admittedly this is a very subjective line to draw, for instance I loved Rails and some people make the same criticism of Rails that I make here for the GraphQL ecosystem.
The tooling around Apollo is pretty good, and that’s great but so many of the “why GraphQL” arguments are either short sided, assume you are doing REST badly, or imply you are an organization that is much bigger and has scaling problems most of the projects I’ve worked on do not have. So far I am very happy I went back to a REST API.
Oh and here’s another REST benefit: when working on my REST API I spend most of my time thinking about good API design and testing practices. When working with GraphQL I spent most of my time figuring out how GraphQL ecosystem libraries worked. I would much rather spend my time thinking about how to do the job well than how to glue together an ecosystem of tools that someone else designed. Admittedly this is a very subjective line to draw, for instance I loved Rails and some people make the same criticism of Rails that I make here for the GraphQL ecosystem.