Comment

Comment by itistoday

Everything on your website that in any way addresses "Dropbox's security" should make absolutely clear the extent to which users can expect their data to be "secure".

In Dropbox's case, users can expect the following:

  - Data is probably secure from sniffers
That's it.

It matters little whether "Drew has physical access to our storage servers anymore". Your code obviously has easy access to the keys used to encrypt and decrypt the data. This means all of the following scenarios are possible:

  - User's data is obtained via the government (users 
    aren't necessarily even informed about this)
  - User's data is obtained by rouge employee (potentially
    leaking to _anyone_ or _anything_)
  - User's data is obtained by hacker (again, implies ZERO 
    assurance of data security).
So don't flash around "AES this or that" without making it absolutely clear to the average user that what you are doing is the equivalent of storing their data in a shed guarded by a lock that can be accessed by anyone who can find (or demand) the key that you've hidden under a rock somewhere.
parent itistoday 15 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton