Comment

Comment by gumby

Having programmed in languages with named parameters (Smalltalk, ObjC and Commonlisp) I’ve found them cumbersome.

Also they can lead to a poor pattern which is functions/methods that take too many parameters.

They also tend to make generics harder to understand as the possible parameters can vary. Of course you can make the same problem in C++ via, say, `auto multiply(int x, int y)` and `auto multiply(double x, double y, enum rounding rp = rounding::nearest)`

In general they impose the verbosity (in keyboarding and reading) in the routine cases but don’t free you from having to look up the argument semantics of lesser-used functions.

Side point: I used “keyboarding” because the obvious word, “typing” has a homonym which made the sentence confusing!

parent gumby 6 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton