Comment

Comment by agarzenm

From the article.

>My main gripe is that the files under /etc/rc.d/ are immutable scripts.

If the files/config (I know the author argues they aren't config files) are truely immutable why would the system upgrade command modify them? and how would it as if they are immutable in the same way that running chattr +i somefile on Linux will make a file immutable even to root then I don't understand how the upgrade command is modifying them.

Systemd-d is growing on me, partly because it is being forced upon us but also because once you get over the initial carpet pull from beneath you, you don't need to be exposed to the extra bullshit it brings.

If you want to experience pain with System-d, install a fresh copy of Ubuntu and try to setup /etc/resolv.conf, for an extra challenge try setup /etc/resolv.conf using unbound as a stub resolver.

I was amazed at how much effort I had to spend fighting the OS to just say "Stop managing this file, do not load this file, I am going to manage it"

I spend most of my time with Linux systems so I admire the simplicity of the System V approach. It is interesting to see other people discuss this from a BSD perspective as I have very little exposure to BSD like systems.

BSD seems great, I love reading the security.html page of the OpenBSD project, it has so many great ideas + implementations.

https://www.openbsd.org/security.html

parent agarzenm 6 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton