Comment

Comment by cousin_it

So 1) spend many paragraphs describing the sinister idea of "birds of a feather" tracking 2) link to a grant that mentions "query flocks", which are similar to parameterized SQL queries and unrelated to "birds of a feather" tracking 3) Larry and Sergey got money from that grant as students, though their eventual result was unrelated to that, as often happens 4) conspiracy confirmed.

> Brin’s breakthrough research on page ranking by tracking user queries and linking them to the many searches conducted—essentially identifying “birds of a feather”

What is this talking about? I'd love to give the author a quick quiz on PageRank. (It's about the link structure of websites, not about queries. Google gave amazing results based on that, long before they had high query volume, that's how they got successful.)

The older I get, the more I realize how damaging Gell-Mann amnesia is. When you read an article making big claims, check the part that intersects with your specialty. If that part is lazy or dishonest, so is the rest of the article.

parent cousin_it 6 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton