Comment

Comment by javajosh

Yes, this seems to be yet another tool that falls prey to what I think of as "The Bisquick Problem". Bisquick is a product that is basically pre-mixed flour, salt, baking powder that you can use to make pancakes, biscuits, and waffles. But why would you buy this instead of its constituent parts? Does Bisquick really save that much time? Is it worth the loss of component flexibility?

Worst of all, if you accept Bisquick, then you open the door to an explosion of Bisquick options. Its a combinatorial explosion of pre-mixed ingredients. In a dystopian future, perhaps people stop buying flour or salt, and the ONLY way you can make food is to buy the right kind of Bisquick. Might make a kind of mash up of a baking show and Black Mirror.

Anyway, yeah, Airflow (and so many other tools) feel like Bisquick. It has all the strengths, but also all the weaknesses, of that model.

parent javajosh 6 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton