As a user, I will absolutely say I love AMP. AMP pages load incredibly fast with much less bullshit.
The real problem is that AMP isn't necessary. Google created AMP and is encouraging (nearly forcing it) it in a very hamfisted way because web developers couldn't figure out how to make responsive, fast-loading web pages without a huge company like Google spelling it out for them with a framework.
Now, obviously to power users like the typical HN user, AMP is evil because it's just Google taking over more of the web.
But understand that to your typical mobile user, AMP is a godsend because of how fast it is. They don't care that the URL shows Google instead of whatever page they think they're on.
As a user, I will absolutely say I love AMP. AMP pages load incredibly fast with much less bullshit.
The real problem is that AMP isn't necessary. Google created AMP and is encouraging (nearly forcing it) it in a very hamfisted way because web developers couldn't figure out how to make responsive, fast-loading web pages without a huge company like Google spelling it out for them with a framework.
Now, obviously to power users like the typical HN user, AMP is evil because it's just Google taking over more of the web.
But understand that to your typical mobile user, AMP is a godsend because of how fast it is. They don't care that the URL shows Google instead of whatever page they think they're on.