It is indeed folly to assume that cattle have no identity. There's an internally famous video inside Google in which a particular well-known machine was unracked, dragged out into a field, and ceremonially smashed to pieces by some hardware techs. Sometimes a machine just takes an arrow to the knee and it's never the same again. Then there are all the uncontrolled or unrecorded differences between machines: the ones at the tops of the racks, or the ends of the rows, are hotter (or colder); there's some difference between the same model of hard disk made in Hungary compared to the ones made in Mexico; at some date the BIOS vendor made an undocumented firmware revision that changes an obscure energy/performance register in your CPU; you have a machine with a dead CMOS battery that worked normally until it was rebooted.
Cattle is a good philosophy but it takes a huge amount of work to approach perfection.
Cattle is a good philosophy but it takes a huge amount of work to approach perfection.