Port knocking was somewhat silly when it was introduced ~20 years ago --- at most, on a reasonably designed network, it was saving you from your own misconfigurations, but at least in 2005 it was reasonable to imagine a highly diverse network of machines that people logged into using multiple protocols, where those misconfigurations were likely.
In 2020, it's gone past "silly" and is now a design smell, in the same way that actually relying on fail2ban would be. Whatever port knocking is doing to help you is a a description of something you're doing wrong with your architecture.
We're not even comfortable with long-lived keys anymore; modern networks are built with short-lived certificates issued off 2FA from an IdP. We have good VPNs right now for the other weird cases. Our networks default to all-ports all-hosts closed. Arguably, port knocking is literally setting your security back, by making it harder for automated tooling to scream bloody murder if you've managed to expose a dev instance unexpectedly to the Internet.
Don't bother. If you've got a single system you're managing outside of a cloud provider with its own decent network firewall, just set up WireGuard and filter everything but that. If it helps, think of WireGuard as the evolution of SPA port knocking.
In 2020, it's gone past "silly" and is now a design smell, in the same way that actually relying on fail2ban would be. Whatever port knocking is doing to help you is a a description of something you're doing wrong with your architecture.
We're not even comfortable with long-lived keys anymore; modern networks are built with short-lived certificates issued off 2FA from an IdP. We have good VPNs right now for the other weird cases. Our networks default to all-ports all-hosts closed. Arguably, port knocking is literally setting your security back, by making it harder for automated tooling to scream bloody murder if you've managed to expose a dev instance unexpectedly to the Internet.
Don't bother. If you've got a single system you're managing outside of a cloud provider with its own decent network firewall, just set up WireGuard and filter everything but that. If it helps, think of WireGuard as the evolution of SPA port knocking.