Comment

Comment by fargle

This is highly biased opinion piece. I like BSD. I liked pre-Oracle Solaris. And I like Linux at lot too.

And it is factually inaccurate. Deprecation of ifconfig is a distro issue. "Linux" did not deprecate it. And the reason is that it was unmaintained, not that it couldn't handle multiple IP addresses. In fact it can, I still use it 50% of the time. Works fine for setting and displaying multiple addresses.

The Debian maintainers wanted to drop it, and the other distros all followed suit a couple years later. Good information and links here:

https://serverfault.com/questions/633087/where-is-the-statem...

"Linux maintains known bugs – and actively refuses to fix them. In fact, if you attempt to fix them, Linus will curse at you, as manifest by this email."

That is a bold statement but is not at all supported by the linked email. You'll see Linus cursing at a bad patch that would break something in userland, not for "maintaining a bug". He's preventing at least two bugs (unnecessary change to behavior and ENOENT is indeed the wrong return value). I think I liked the old Linus better...

So it's a shame. I'd love to read a series about BSD, but this is really just inaccurate propaganda.

parent fargle 6 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton