Comment

Comment by amflare

I still don't get it. The ballot is effectively a pivot between the voter and the result. You can't just disconnect this without sacrificing the integrity of the system. If you scramble it so that the vote and the ballot are disconnected, there is no way to prove the results are valid. And if you disconnect the voter from the ballot, you can make up all the votes you want.

But let's say the Input->Output is reproducible all the time with no chain between the voter and the result. You /still/ have no way to ensure that the checkbox corresponded with the name, and that you cast the vote you think you did. Perhaps this is outside the scope of the article, but its a fairly glaring deficiency.

Perhaps I'm misunderstanding. But all you can tell with this system is that "your" ballot went into the magic box and a (presumably reproducible) result came out the other side.

parent amflare 7 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton