Comment

Comment by mytailorisrich

Having a requirement to link a SIM to an individual is not privacy erosion.

It does not mean that usage is monitored, and usage is the important privacy aspect.

Furthermore, this just puts mobile phones on par with landlines. It used to be that having a phone meant having a landline at home, and obviously that meant knowing exactly who a number belonged to.

There needs to be a balance for everything in the real world. And even most Western countries have concluded that requiring IDs for SIM cards is a necessary measure.

Now, for Chinese authorities one issue (without even going into politics) is that China is a very low trust society where it is almost expected that everyone will flaunt the rules at the first opportunity. So I am half guessing that the government sees technological solutions as a way around that.

(As for renting a room, it would be crazy for a landlord not to know who their tenant is just for practical reasons considering land and tenancy laws in most EU countries)

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton