Comment

Comment by debatem1

All crypto is difficult to get right unless you're a crypto expert. RSA is not unusual in this regard.

The thing that is unusual about RSA is how many people /kind of/ understand it. Crypto people who dislike RSA say that this leads to a proliferation of terrible RSA implementations, and that it is therefore more dangerous to use than eg ECC. Crypto people who like RSA say that its relative accessibility makes it a more popular target, and that in the absence of a catastrophic break the more-studied cryptosystem should be assumed to be more secure.

Personally I've spent some time recently with badly implemented ECC, and I don't think the mistakes being made there are fundamentally different from or rarer than the mistakes you see in poorly implemented RSA.

parent debatem1 7 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton