Here's a real example of how HSTS can break a site: My personal, non-public wiki is secured by HTTPS with a certificate valid for 5 years. I thought it would be neat to enable HSTS for it because what could go wrong?
Well, just last week the HTTPS certificate expired in the middle of the day. I had about a half days' worth of work typed up into the browser's text field and when I clicked "submit", all of my work vanished and Firefox only showed a page stating that the certificate was invalid and that nothing could be done about it. I clicked the back button, same thing. Forward button, same thing. A half-days worth of work vanished into thin air.
Is this my fault for letting the certificate expire? Absolutely. Should I have used letsencrypt so I didn't have to worry about it. Sure. Should I be using a notes system that doesn't throw away my work when there's a problem saving it? Definitely. I don't deny that there's lots that I could have done to prevent this from being a problem and lots that I need to fix in the future.
But it does point out that if you use HSTS, you have to be _really_ sure that _all_ your ducks are in a row or it _will_ come back to bite you eventually.
Well, just last week the HTTPS certificate expired in the middle of the day. I had about a half days' worth of work typed up into the browser's text field and when I clicked "submit", all of my work vanished and Firefox only showed a page stating that the certificate was invalid and that nothing could be done about it. I clicked the back button, same thing. Forward button, same thing. A half-days worth of work vanished into thin air.
Is this my fault for letting the certificate expire? Absolutely. Should I have used letsencrypt so I didn't have to worry about it. Sure. Should I be using a notes system that doesn't throw away my work when there's a problem saving it? Definitely. I don't deny that there's lots that I could have done to prevent this from being a problem and lots that I need to fix in the future.
But it does point out that if you use HSTS, you have to be _really_ sure that _all_ your ducks are in a row or it _will_ come back to bite you eventually.