Comment

Comment by devonkim

Furthermore, as computers get faster and cheaper in every dimension what makes economic sense to use “Big Data” tooling and efforts gets substantially larger with it. The limits of single nodes 15 years ago were pretty serious but most problems businesses have even in the so-called enterprise can currently easily fit on a workstation costing maybe $5k and be crunched through in a couple hours or maybe minutes - a lot easier to deal with than multiple Spark or Hana nodes. Operationalizing the analysis to more than a single group of users or problem is where things get more interesting but I’ve seen very, very few companies that have the business needs to necessitate all this stuff at scale - most business leaders still seem to treat analytics results in discrete blocks via monthly / weekly reports and seem quite content with reports and findings that take hours to run. Usually when some crunching takes days to run it’s not because the processing itself takes a lot of CPU but because some ancient systems never intended to be used at that scale are the bottleneck or manual processes are still required so the critical path isn’t being touched at all by investing more in modern tools.

I can support “misguided” Big Data projects from a political perspective if they help fund fixing the fundamental problems (similar to Agile consultants) that plague an organization, but most consultants are not going to do very well by suggesting going back and fixing something unrelated to their core value proposition itself. For example, if you hire a bunch of machine learning engineers and they all say “we need to spend months or even years cleaning up and tagging your completely unstructured data slop because nothing we have can work without clean data” that’ll probably frustrate the people paying them $1MM+ / year each to get some results ASAP. The basics are missing by default and it’s why the non-tech companies are falling further and further behind despite massive investments in technology - technology is not a silver bullet to crippling organizational and business problems (this is pretty much the TL;DR of 15+ years of “devops” for me at least).

parent devonkim 7 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton