Comment

Comment by platz

Google Keep is an interesting because it's hard to exactly categorize exactly what it is, or exactly what use case it attempts support.

It's kind of like a crossover between a private Pinterest, a bookmarking app, and a note taking app.

So it's multi-paradigm.

But of you know your use case better, you can tailor your soltution to fit.

You can then make better decisions on online/offline, where to store state, web vs native etc.. this is the benefit of simplyfing and clarifying your use case.

For example, I am a heavy bookmarker (~70k bookmarks), so I built an open-source, self-hosted (I don't want to own your bookmarks) bookmarking web app (https://github.com/jonschoning/espial). It is pretty minimal, but it is tailored to quickly bookmarks while browsing. I didn't bother with native because I am already in a browser context when I want to bookmark something.

But maybe I am just biased towards web hosted tech. I just don't see the value add for native unless it's doing something intimately connected with the physical device or physical user.

parent platz 7 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton