OK, read the article starting with the phrase "But that would be overlooking something important".
Normally, "read the article" is a bit not-HN-friendly, but when you call someone out as disingenuous because they didn't say things that they in fact do clearly call out and have a multi-paragraph discussion of, you are earning a "please read the article" response. They're not being disingenuous about what they are doing if they clearly explain what that is and then have a (IMHO) balanced pro-and-con discussion about it.
Normally, "read the article" is a bit not-HN-friendly, but when you call someone out as disingenuous because they didn't say things that they in fact do clearly call out and have a multi-paragraph discussion of, you are earning a "please read the article" response. They're not being disingenuous about what they are doing if they clearly explain what that is and then have a (IMHO) balanced pro-and-con discussion about it.