Comment

Comment by jariz

Yes, so let's all keep reinventing the wheel, over and over again.

I know the author uses pretty extreme examples, but I still don't see what's inherently wrong with the mentioned packages.

- it does what you think it does:

`isOdd(2)` is a lot easier to understand than `value % 2`

- even though most of these are one liners, it's one line of code less that you have to maintain

- if the package is at least somewhat popular, it's highly likely it has measures for edge cases; stuff I wouldn't have thought of when writing it myself.

On top of that, mentioning left-pad is really cliche and weak at this point (bear in mind this happend 2 years ago), npm has taken measures and nothing similar has happend since then, and even then, it was still a fairly isolated event - the whole thing actually took 10 minutes.

I'd much rather take a rare, yet-to-happen-again chance that a package goes down, over having to rewrite simple utility functions over and over again, every month.

parent jariz 8 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton