> They won't be able to tell you why they prefer the one with more time invested in the UX/UI, but they will almost always choose that one.
do you really believe that or does your job depending on you and others, believing that? I get UX is important, where UX is defined by such things like "number of clicks to achieve a task", but the OP was talking about margins and padding etc which just are a lot less important than designers like to think. It's probably an uncomfortable truth for people who spend all day tweaking things 1px at a time, but I think it's largely true.
It's prettier, I can see that. If it was a painting I'd rather hang the new one than the old one on my wall, but when it comes to pure functionality (read a list of links) the current (ugly) design is better (imho).
do you really believe that or does your job depending on you and others, believing that? I get UX is important, where UX is defined by such things like "number of clicks to achieve a task", but the OP was talking about margins and padding etc which just are a lot less important than designers like to think. It's probably an uncomfortable truth for people who spend all day tweaking things 1px at a time, but I think it's largely true.
A case in point is the new Reddit design being tested (https://media.wired.com/photos/5abed25228f0c90b2647ac08/mast...)
It's prettier, I can see that. If it was a painting I'd rather hang the new one than the old one on my wall, but when it comes to pure functionality (read a list of links) the current (ugly) design is better (imho).