The author makes it seem that everybody is eager to use voice assistants to replace their Android or iOS screen interactions. But I don’t know anybody who would dictate their private messages on the subway, or even at home - they are called private for a reason. And just imagine requesting „tell me the current value of a bitcoin“ while at work - I don’t think this would go well.
There would be a lot of noise pollution everywhere, with people constantly murmuring to themselves, alternated with an unresponsive silence while listening to the device‘s answer. It would seem like everybody is on the phone, all the time. Also, for me, digesting information via text is way easier, because I can jump back and forth to support short term memory - good luck with that with a voice assistant.
The iPhone (and friends) disrupted the PC because they made reading and writing mobile. Voice assistants are not iterating on this paradigm, but they are rather iterating on phone calls. I‘m skeptical that this is suitable to replace the iPhone I‘m writing this on.
There would be a lot of noise pollution everywhere, with people constantly murmuring to themselves, alternated with an unresponsive silence while listening to the device‘s answer. It would seem like everybody is on the phone, all the time. Also, for me, digesting information via text is way easier, because I can jump back and forth to support short term memory - good luck with that with a voice assistant.
The iPhone (and friends) disrupted the PC because they made reading and writing mobile. Voice assistants are not iterating on this paradigm, but they are rather iterating on phone calls. I‘m skeptical that this is suitable to replace the iPhone I‘m writing this on.