Comment

Comment by zx2c4

This is why I don't run any Electron apps on my computers at all, ever.

That means I'm stuck with the web browser version of Slack, Skype, Signal (going away), and so forth, which is a shame. But it's better than the security nightmare that is Electron.

I wish developers wanting to make cross platform GUI applications would look instead at Qt. It's extremely easy to use, really fast, and generates great GUIs. It's been around for ages and continually sees updates. Usually people who see the Qt light are pretty satisfied. It can also be used from a wide variety of languages, in case you're not into writing C++.

I sort of suspect that Electron's popularity is due to it being accessible to the hordes of JavaScript developers who otherwise wouldn't have had any clue how to make desktop/native applications. However, do I really want to be running unsandboxed xss==>rce code written by clueless devs? No, no I do not. So, in the end, refusing to run Electron apps turns out to be a somewhat reasonable security posture.

parent zx2c4 9 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton