Comment

Comment by rhino369

Like the article says, "Criminal law punishes bad intentions and bad acts, not traffic accidents.”

Accidents happen. There is no reason to ruin two lives instead of one, by harshly punishing another person.

If driver A takes the .002% chance they'll cause an accident while driving on the phone and drive B takes the same .002% chance, it makes no sense to throw B in jail and let A off with a 50 dollar fine just because driver B actually hit someone. Drive B should be liable for all medical costs and lost income.

But society gains nothing by punishing her. It's just a way to make us all feel more control. Accidents only happen to bad criminals! Good folks like us would never have an accident!

parent rhino369 9 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton